More than half of Kiwi employees are ‘de-motivated’

by |

Every second employee in New Zealand and Australia works in a ‘de-energising’ organisational climate, according to research.

The latest report from Hay Group* paints a poor report card on the state of engagement between organisations, its managers and employees. The problem, it was found, is that direct managers continually fail to provide an environment that drives employees to succeed.

“Given the research found only 48% of employees find their work climate energising and engaging, one must conclude that the health of relations between employees and managers is cause for concern,” Wendy Montague from Hay Group said.

Low engagement levels have a significant impact not only the productivity of an organisation but the overall competitiveness of the ANZ region. Employee performance has been found to account for a differential in business results of up to 30%, so creating an energising work environment which encourages employees to put in that little bit extra can mean the difference between achieving an average or a high-performing organisation.

On the upside, the research highlighted some key strengths of Australian and New Zealand managers, and 73% of employees said they are given the autonomy they need to get on with their work, reflecting a degree of trust for employees to take initiative and use their own judgment. 

The research also revealed 62% of employees feel dedicated to their work and their company which is good news for organisations that have weathered the difficult economy over the past years.

It was found that the biggest gaps exist between the actual and the desired work environment; clarity; standards and rewards.

Clarity: The largest gap between the ‘actual’ and the ‘ideal’ when it comes to the employee’s view of the organisational climate is in the dimension of clarity. Clarity has two aspects for employees – the first is how well an individual understands how their role  relates to ‘the big picture’, the goals and direction of the company; and the second aspect is how well do they  know what is expected of them in the role. If someone is unclear about what is expected of them in their role, how can they deliver? Only by understanding what their role is and what is expected, can an employee actively drive and achieve the broader company purpose.

Standards: Managers can establish high standards of performance and work behaviours in their teams by involving team members in suggesting, setting, reviewing and amending individual and team goals. People perform at their best when they are encouraged to improve their performance and aim higher to reach challenging yet achievable goals. When an organisation and its leaders have a vision for improvement and bringing out the best in people, this provides the inspiration and drive for employees to turn vision into reality.

Rewards related to performance: It is critical for managers to give consistent, constructive feedback to individuals and the team in order to ensure that all team members know what high performance looks like. The recent research showed that providing feedback and coaching to employees wasn’t part of the behavioural repertoire of many ANZ leaders with many managers finding it difficult to address performance, either positive or negative, as well as providing developmental feedback to their staff. Managers need to start introducing reward engagement practices in to the workplace in order to motivate their employees to deliver stronger performances day in and day out.

The six dimensions of organisational climate

  1. Flexibility. There are no unnecessary rules, procedures, policies, or practices. New ideas are easily accepted.
  2. Responsibility. Employees are given authority to accomplish tasks without having to constantly check for approval.
  3. Standards. Challenging but attainable goals are set for the organisation and its employees.
  4. Rewards. Employees are recognised and rewarded for good performance.
  5. Clarity. Everyone within the organisation knows what is expected of him or her.
  6. Team Commitment. People are proud to belong to the organisation.

*More than 3,100 managers from across Australia and New Zealand and 15,400 employees that report directly into these managers participated in the research.

  • Brent Bailey on 22/11/2012 9:12:08 a.m.

    Another thing worth considering is the ongoing headcount reductions that seem to have become part of the employment picture. Having to reapply for your own job every Christmas can grind down anyone's state of engagement.
    How can we be expected to get up a 5.00am and kill for our product when employers simply do not reciprocate. Staff are just flicked off the bus as and when it suits the employer. Is ity any wonder we just act like wage slaves. Try making a committment to your people see how that can make a huge difference.

HRD Forum is the place for positive industry interaction and welcomes your professional and informed opinion.

Name (required)
Comment (required)
By submitting, I agree to the Terms & Conditions